Unfamiliar to most, this pie is no stranger to those who hail from Indiana or any parts of Amish country. Not to be confused with custard pie, this confection is a perfect mix of sugar and cream with a creme brûlée -like finish.
Full size pie - 9 inches - will serve 8 - 12 people
Due to large volume of orders - PLEASE note, your pie will be ready AT or AFTER the time slot you pick, not BEFORE. Please plan accordingly when choosing a time for pickup.
Due to the handmade nature of all our pies, please note that your pie might vary from the pictured pie.
